Data partitioning is one of the most overlooked yet critical...
Read More
Data partitioning is one of the most overlooked yet critical aspects of building a high performance data lake on Amazon S3. The way you partition data determines how efficiently it can be queried, processed, and scaled for analytics tools like Athena, Presto, or Redshift Spectrum.
However, many teams fall into what experts call the “S3 partition trap.” They over partition, use the wrong keys, or neglect file optimization, in turn creating performance bottlenecks and inflating AWS costs.
In this post, inspired by insights from Luminous Men, we’ll break down how not to partition data in S3, identify the common mistakes that slow down your pipelines, and outline the best practices for building a data structure that actually scales.
The S3 Partition Trap Explained
Partitioning is meant to make your data easier to manage and query. But when done incorrectly, it can lead to millions of tiny files, uneven data distribution, and long query times.
Let’s look at some of the most common mistakes teams make, and what to do instead.
1. Over Partitioning by Too Many Keys
An easy way to wreck S3 performance is by adding too many partition levels.
Example:
s3://my-bucket/logs/year=2025/month=10/day=09/hour=15/minute=30/
While detailed partitions sound helpful, they explode into thousands of small directories. Query engines like Athena must perform countless metadata lookups, drastically slowing query execution.
Better approach:
Keep partition granularity aligned with your query filters. If analysts only query by day, then stop at year/month/day. Deeper levels add unnecessary overhead.
2. Using High Cardinality Columns as Partition Keys
Partitioning by identifiers like user_id or transaction_id may seem logical but results in millions of partitions, with each partition having tiny amounts of data. This makes scans inefficient and metadata handling expensive.
Better approach:
Partition on low cardinality columns such as date, region, or data_type. Use filters or indexes inside your data (e.g., in Parquet) for high cardinality attributes.
3. Skewed Partition Sizes (Uneven Data Distribution)
If one partition holds terabytes of data and others only a few megabytes, performance suffers due to data skew. Query engines process partitions unevenly, and jobs take longer to complete.
Better approach:
Regularly analyze partition sizes using AWS Glue or Lake Formation. Merge small partitions and split large ones to balance workloads.
4. Ignoring File Size Optimization
Tiny files are a silent performance killer. Query engines must open and close each one, creating massive overhead. On the other hand, oversized files (>1 GB) reduce parallel read efficiency.
Better approach:
Target 128 MB–512 MB per file when using Parquet or ORC formats. Use ETL tools such as AWS Glue, Apache Spark, or Delta Lake to compact small files automatically.
5. Storing Data in Inefficient Formats
Text based formats like CSV or JSON are easy to work with but horribly inefficient for analytical queries. These formats force full file scans even when you only need one column.
Better approach:
Convert to columnar formats such as Parquet or ORC, which allow selective column reads, compression, and faster filtering.
6. Neglecting Data Lifecycle and Retention
Unmanaged data lakes grow endlessly, leading to high storage bills and slower queries.
Better approach:
Set S3 lifecycle policies to move cold data to Glacier or Deep Archive after a defined period. Partition by date so you can easily exclude old data from queries.
Smarter Strategies for S3 Partitioning
Now that we’ve covered what not to do, here’s how to get it right.
✅ 1. Partition Based on Access Patterns
Structure your data according to how it’s queried, not how it’s generated.
If analysts typically filter by region and date, design your S3 keys accordingly:
s3://data-lake/analytics/year=2025/month=10/region=us-west/
This ensures that queries only scan relevant folders, minimizing cost and latency.
✅ 2. Keep Partition Depth Manageable
Limit yourself to two or three partition levels. Shallow hierarchies are easier to maintain and perform better with Athena or Spark.
✅ 3. Automate Metadata Management
Whenever new partitions are added, your data catalog must know about them. Use AWS Glue Data Catalog or Hive Metastore to automatically register new partitions as data lands in S3.
✅ 4. Compact Data Regularly
Over time, ingestion jobs generate many small files. Schedule periodic compaction jobs to merge them into optimally sized chunks. Tools like Delta Lake or Apache Iceberg can automate this with transaction support.
✅ 5. Monitor and Tune Continuously
Partitioning isn’t a “set and forget” task. Track your data growth, query patterns, and partition sizes over time. Adjust your strategy as datasets evolve.
Recommended Tools for Efficient Partitioning
| Tool | Purpose | Key Benefit |
|---|---|---|
| AWS Glue | ETL and metadata cataloging | Automates partition discovery and schema management |
| Apache Iceberg | Table format for S3 data | Enables ACID transactions and time travel |
| Delta Lake | Optimized data layer | Simplifies compaction and schema evolution |
| AWS Athena | Serverless querying | Pay-per-query analytics on partitioned data |
| Apache Spark | Distributed computation | Ideal for repartitioning and data optimization tasks |
The Business Impact of Smarter Partitioning
Well designed S3 partitions don’t just improve performance they reduce operational cost and complexity.
Organizations that follow partitioning best practices achieve:
- Up to 80% lower query costs on Athena and Spectrum
- Faster insights thanks to optimized scans
- Simplified compliance with better data governance
- Greater scalability for growing analytics workloads
When your data is structured intelligently, your S3 bucket becomes a true data platform, not a dumping ground.
Conclusion
Falling into the S3 partition trap is easy, but escaping it pays off quickly. Over partitioning, poor key selection, and unmanaged small files all lead to slow, expensive analytics.
The solution is to partition by access pattern, use columnar formats, and automate lifecycle and compaction workflows. With the right structure and governance, your data lake becomes faster, cheaper, and far easier to manage.
Call to Action
💬 Have you faced performance issues in S3 due to poor partitioning?
👉 Share your lessons or success stories in the comments below!
📩 Subscribe to our newsletter for more cloud data optimization and AWS best-practice guides.
Google NotebookLM Expands with AI-Powered Audio Overviews: A New Way to Learn and Create
Artificial intelligence continues to reshape the way we absorb, organize,...
Read More
Third Party Data Breach Statistics 2025: How Vendor Risks Threaten Enterprise Security
In today’s interconnected business environment, third party vendors play a...
Read More
Escaping the Digital Cave: How to Lead Your Team Through True Digital Transformation
In today’s rapidly evolving business landscape, technology alone doesn’t define...
Read More
Leave a Reply